You Season 4 Star Tilly Keeper Confesses To Stealing An R-Rated Prop From Set
Mia Phillips
Updated on March 07, 2026
Tilly Keeper's confession to taking home her "You" character's unusual candles comes in an interview with Cosmopolitan UK. "I stole something. I stole penis candles," Keeper admitted. "I've got one in my cupboard somewhere. Well, when you light them they don't melt very nicely, they don't keep their shape. It's a nice idea but not very well executed."
She went on to share that the candle managed to cause some havoc in her home life: "My dad was horrified when he stumbled upon it."
It's unfortunate that the candles seen in "You" don't seem to earn a passing grade as a decorative candle, but a product like that tends to serve as more of a novelty or gag gift anyway. Still, it's probably difficult to resist stealing such a unique (and disposable) prop from a set, and it wouldn't be surprising if a few more of those candles ended up in the homes of other "You" cast members.
The first five episodes of "You" Season 4 are now streaming on Netflix.